Top Ad Widget

Collapse

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Three years ago, during the opening day of bear season I saw a black bear that was limping badly on three legs. The bear was holding his injured front leg up. The bear would hop more then walk. I passed up and didn't shoot this bear that day because

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Three years ago, during the opening day of bear season I saw a black bear that was limping badly on three legs. The bear was holding his injured front leg up. The bear would hop more then walk. I passed up and didn't shoot this bear that day because

    Three years ago, during the opening day of bear season I saw a black bear that was limping badly on three legs. The bear was holding his injured front leg up. The bear would hop more then walk. I passed up and didn't shoot this bear that day because he was an average size bear. I wanted to shoot a large four hundred pound boar seen on my trail cam photos. My hunting family and friends said I should do a mercy killing on that bear. The bear can't run or climb to escape danger so a huge bear could kill it. I already bagged three average size bears in the past and wanted a huge bear. What would you have done on that first day of bear season?

  • #2
    Had the bear been infected I would have shot it and presented it to a game manager for a new tag. (WI reissues tags in cases like this) If it was an old injury that had healed I would pass as you did.

    Comment


    • #3
      That's such a tough call. I know animals can survive some pretty horrendous injuries. I would think a front leg would be better hurt than a back one too. I know that deer and bear are different, but I jumped a fawn that was missing a front leg one early fall at the farm I hunt. As it ran, it was stumbling pretty badly and I thought about dispatching it then but didn't. I played that decision over in my head for the rest of that year until I saw a mature doe missing a front leg in the same part of the timber the next fall. I have seen her now for the last three seasons and it's hard to tell that anything is wrong with her until you see the missing leg. Maybe that bear you passed has now become another 400 pound boar.

      Comment


      • #4
        That's a tough call, and one I've had to make with deer a couple of times. For me it really depends on whether I think it has a chance of recovering. If I think it does, I will pass it, but if not, I would probably shoot it. But on the other hand, just to play Devil's Advocate, do we really need to be dispatching wild animals just because we think it would be "humane"? Nature by its very definition is not humane or merciful, so there is a legitimate argument to be made for letting things run their natural course in these cases. After all, wild predators and scavengers have to eat too. Not an easy decision, for sure.

        Comment


        • #5
          I think huntfishtrap has a good handle on it. We can make these decisions in either direction, but it isn't our job to direct Mother Nature.

          Comment


          • #6
            I always thought the right answer was to take it, but I'm no longer so sure.
            I mentioned to a neighbor a couple of months ago that I wondered how a particular old three legged doe in our neck of the woods did as tough as this past winter was. I had been keeping an eye out to take her down during archery the last two falls thinking that one difficult winter would be a starvation sentence for her.
            The neighbor informed me that he hasn't seen her out and about, but had her on his game camera with triplets this spring.
            I don't always know what I think I know.

            Comment


            • #7
              Gary, I think you were acting selfish. You should have taken the bear and put it out of its misery. Also, a wounded bear could be a greater danger to people.

              Comment


              • #8
                Originally posted by jcarlin View Post
                I always thought the right answer was to take it, but I'm no longer so sure.
                I mentioned to a neighbor a couple of months ago that I wondered how a particular old three legged doe in our neck of the woods did as tough as this past winter was. I had been keeping an eye out to take her down during archery the last two falls thinking that one difficult winter would be a starvation sentence for her.
                The neighbor informed me that he hasn't seen her out and about, but had her on his game camera with triplets this spring.
                I don't always know what I think I know.
                Still would be better to take the three-legged deer.

                Comment


                • #9
                  Originally posted by pineywoods View Post
                  I think huntfishtrap has a good handle on it. We can make these decisions in either direction, but it isn't our job to direct Mother Nature.
                  I'm not going to let an animal suffer needlessly.

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Originally posted by huntfishtrap View Post
                    That's a tough call, and one I've had to make with deer a couple of times. For me it really depends on whether I think it has a chance of recovering. If I think it does, I will pass it, but if not, I would probably shoot it. But on the other hand, just to play Devil's Advocate, do we really need to be dispatching wild animals just because we think it would be "humane"? Nature by its very definition is not humane or merciful, so there is a legitimate argument to be made for letting things run their natural course in these cases. After all, wild predators and scavengers have to eat too. Not an easy decision, for sure.
                    Good question. However, the bear was legal. Besides, a wounded baer could be a danger to other people.

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Originally posted by 4everAutumn View Post
                      That's such a tough call. I know animals can survive some pretty horrendous injuries. I would think a front leg would be better hurt than a back one too. I know that deer and bear are different, but I jumped a fawn that was missing a front leg one early fall at the farm I hunt. As it ran, it was stumbling pretty badly and I thought about dispatching it then but didn't. I played that decision over in my head for the rest of that year until I saw a mature doe missing a front leg in the same part of the timber the next fall. I have seen her now for the last three seasons and it's hard to tell that anything is wrong with her until you see the missing leg. Maybe that bear you passed has now become another 400 pound boar.
                      Maybe this, maybe that. I would have shot.

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Originally posted by charlie elk View Post
                        Had the bear been infected I would have shot it and presented it to a game manager for a new tag. (WI reissues tags in cases like this) If it was an old injury that had healed I would pass as you did.
                        Charlie, he probably couldn't tell if it was an infected wound.

                        Comment

                        Welcome!

                        Collapse

                        Welcome to Outdoor Life's Answers section. Here you will find hunting, fishing, and survival tips from the editors of Outdoor Life, as well as recommendations from readers like yourself.

                        If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ for information on posting and navigating the forums.

                        And don't forget to check out the latest reviews on guns and outdoor gear on outdoorlife.com.

                        Right Rail 1 Ad

                        Collapse

                        Top Active Users

                        Collapse

                        There are no top active users.

                        Right Rail 2 Ad

                        Collapse

                        Latest Topics

                        Collapse

                        Right Rail 3 Ad

                        Collapse

                        Footer Ad Widget

                        Collapse
                        Working...
                        X