Top Ad Widget



No announcement yet.

Cartridge Reloading: Why are Boxer or Berdian primers on none brass cartridges like steel, aluminium and some plastic can't be

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Cartridge Reloading: Why are Boxer or Berdian primers on none brass cartridges like steel, aluminium and some plastic can't be

    Cartridge Reloading: Why are Boxer or Berdian primers on none brass cartridges like steel, aluminium and some plastic can't be reloaded and not recommended to do so? They are once reloaded for us consumers at the factory to start, used once, then scraped. I do reloading as a hobby and alot for our Fish & Game Club. Reuseable brass is becoming sacarce and would like to know if the mention cases can be reloaded and or if special dies and equipment are available for such safe relaoading applications. Alfred Pettit Jr.

  • #2
    Berdan primers use different flash holes and cannot be easily removed without damaging the case. There isn't a simple efficient method for converting them to the boxer primers used in reloading components, so they are basically unusable for the hobby reloader.

    The reason you cannot safely reload aluminum and steel cases is because of stretch and metal fatigue. When the round is fired, the case temporarily expands and then partially contracts. Brass is maliable and can take multiple stretching/contracting cycles while maintaining its elasticity. The same is true of the thick plastic shotgun hulls. The metal used in steel and aluminum cases has very different qualities. Working the metal makes it brittle and therefore any reloaded round would be very dangerous. There are descriptions and lots of warnings of this in reloading manuals.

    After recycling the steel or aluminum, its a toss up if reloading saves much money when it comes to common military caliber ammunition most shooters use at plinking ranges. Consider for example 1000 rounds of new production 223 or 762x39 can be had for less than $120. The primer, powder, and bullets alone will come close in cost, not including brass or your time at the reloading bench.

    So why isn't all ammo made with these cheaper cases? There are downsides. Case dimensions for any given caliber are modified to compensate for the changed expansion properties. There isn't an exact standard to gun chambers, so some guns will get stuck and jam them constantly. Proper annealing techniques allow these metals to be used as cartridge cases without exploding when it expands the first time but a casehead will rip off during extraction if the annealing job wasn't perfect. This leaves you with an unusable gun until you can get the rest of the case out with a special removal tool. Since steel is susceptible to rust, special lubricating coatings are applied to try to compensate. It helps, but the cases are not long-term weatherproof by any means with the headache of the coating wearing off and building up inside the chamber and bolt face of the gun.

    So why are steel and aluminum available? It's all about money. Government military groups around the world want cheap ammunition and arms to supply their troops. Armies don't pick up brass from the battlefield to reload, so one-time-use ammo is perfectly okay. Their guns are all the same caliber with crome lined chambers designed to match up with the steel case dimensions. The end result is a fairly reliable one-time use product at low cost.




    Welcome to Outdoor Life's Answers section. Here you will find hunting, fishing, and survival tips from the editors of Outdoor Life, as well as recommendations from readers like yourself.

    If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ for information on posting and navigating the forums.

    And don't forget to check out the latest reviews on guns and outdoor gear on

    Right Rail 1 Ad


    Top Active Users


    There are no top active users.

    Right Rail 2 Ad


    Latest Topics


    • 6.5-284 Borden/Alpine clone XP works great in the field - 588 yards
      by Ernie
      Dan Ekstrom and I have been looking for a shooter mule deer buck on public land.

      For this area, Tuesday was the last day.

      Yesterday, 10:06 AM
    • Outdoor Life archives
      by Scott123
      Has anyone missed reading Outdoor Life cover to cover archives? I get the run around on the phone about it may come back. Anyone else read it besides...
      10-23-2020, 11:23 PM
    • Blade Stain
      by jhjimbo
      Anybody have tips for getting stains off knife blades. I have a nice, K-Bar I would like to clean up and a 3" Western. All different kinds of stains,...
      10-23-2020, 11:40 AM
    • Home Defense
      by jhjimbo
      If you are using your bird gun for double duty of house defense remember to remove the plug. Might as well have full magazine capacity. Also, I have...
      10-20-2020, 02:15 PM
    • Pay it forward
      by fitch270
      I'm not sure how much interest this will generate but I figured I'd give it a shot and see how it goes. As a way of saying thanks for the help and entertainment...
      10-18-2020, 01:34 PM

    Right Rail 3 Ad


    Footer Ad Widget